- Suma is swimming in a pond.
- A donkey is carrying a load on its back.
- A windmill is lifting water from a well.
- A green plant is carrying out photosynthesis.
- An engine is pulling a train.
- Food grains are getting dried in the sun.
- A sailboat is moving due to wind energy.
Theory / Concept
›
In Physics, work has a very specific meaning. Work is said to be done only when a force acts on an object and produces displacement in the direction of the applied force or in a direction having a component along the force.
Mathematically,
where,
- \(W\) = Work done
- \(F\) = Applied force
- \(s\) = Displacement of the object in the direction of force
If the displacement is not in the direction of the applied force, then the work done depends upon the angle between force and displacement.
The general expression is
where \(\theta\) is the angle between the applied force and displacement.
Therefore, to decide whether work is done or not, always check the following conditions:
- A force must act on the object.
- The object must undergo displacement.
- The displacement should have a component along the direction of the applied force.
Step-by-step Plan
›
Identify whether a force is acting.
Check whether the object moves.
Compare the direction of force with the direction of displacement.
Conclude whether mechanical work is done.
Complete Solution
›
- 1. Suma is swimming in a pond
- Suma pushes the water backward using her hands and legs. According to Newton's Third Law, the water pushes her forward.
- A force is applied on the water.
- Due to the reaction force, Suma moves forward.
- There is displacement in the direction of the force acting on Suma.
- Therefore, mechanical work is done.
- 2. A donkey is carrying a load on its back
- The donkey applies an upward force on the load to balance its weight.
- Force on the load is vertically upward.
- The load moves horizontally with the donkey.
- The angle between force and displacement is \(90^\circ\)
- Hence,\[W = Fs\cos90^\circ\]
- Since,\[\cos90^\circ=0\]
- Therefore,\[W=0\]
- Hence, no mechanical work is done by the donkey on the load.
- 3. A windmill is lifting water from a well
- The rotating blades of the windmill convert wind energy into mechanical energy.
- The windmill exerts an upward force on the water.
- Water moves upward.
- Force and displacement are in the same direction.
- Therefore, mechanical work is done.
- A green plant is carrying out photosynthesis
- Photosynthesis is a biochemical process in which light energy is converted into chemical energy.
- Although energy conversion takes place, there is no mechanical force producing displacement of an object.
- Therefore, no mechanical work is done in the Physics sense.
- An engine is pulling a train
- The engine exerts a pulling force on the train.
- A forward force acts on the train.
- The train moves forward.
- Force and displacement are in the same direction.
- Hence, mechanical work is done.
- Food grains are getting dried in the sun
- The Sun provides heat energy, causing evaporation of water from the grains.
- However, the grains themselves do not undergo displacement because of an applied mechanical force.
- Therefore, no mechanical work is done.
- A sailboat is moving due to wind energy
- Wind strikes the sail and exerts a force on it.
- Wind applies force on the sail.
- The boat moves forward.
- Force causes displacement.
- Hence, mechanical work is done.
›
Exam Significance
›
- This question develops the fundamental concept of mechanical work, which is one of the most frequently tested concepts in CBSE examinations.
- Students learn to distinguish between the everyday meaning of work and its scientific definition.
- Questions based on identifying whether work is positive, negative or zero frequently appear in school examinations, Olympiads and entrance examinations.
- Understanding the relationship between force and displacement forms the foundation for later topics such as energy, power, kinetic energy, potential energy and the Work-Energy Theorem.
- The example of the donkey carrying a load is one of the most commonly asked conceptual questions in CBSE, NTSE, Olympiad and other competitive examinations.
Key Takeaways
›
-
Work is done only when a force produces displacement.
-
Both force and displacement are necessary for mechanical work.
-
If displacement is zero, work done is zero.
-
If force is perpendicular to displacement, then\[ W=0 \]
-
Heat, light and chemical reactions may involve energy transfer, but they do not necessarily involve mechanical work.
-
Always analyse three things: force, displacement and their relative direction before deciding whether work is done.
